Showing posts with label people - Pappé; Ilan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label people - Pappé; Ilan. Show all posts

May 24, 2024

Ilan Pappé on Zionism and the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians

The Nakba is a bit of a misleading term because it means in Arabic "a catastrophe."  It really, what the Palestinians suffered, was not a natural catastrophe, rather ethnic cleansing, which is a clear policy motivated by clear ideology.  And that policy was part - and a total part - of the Zionist program for Palestine from the very inception of the movement in the late 19th century.

Of course very early on they didn't have the capacity to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from their homeland.  But already in the mid 1920s, when the Zionist community in Palestine was still very small, it was able, through purchase of land on which there were many Palestinian villages, to convince the British Mandatory power to evict thirteen Palestinian villages, and that was between 1925 and 1926.  And then slowly this process of buying land and evicting the people who lived on this for hundreds of years brought the Zionist movement where it purchased at least 6% of the land of Palestine, which was of course not enough.  

And then they went to the big ethnic cleansing of 1948.  But as we know, it didn't stop in 1948.  Israel continued to expel Palestinian villages between '48 and '67 [which formed to move] the Palestinian minority in Israel which were allegedly citizens of Israel.  Israel expelled 300,000 Palestinians during the Six-Days War in June 1967.  And since June 1967 until today about 600,000 Palestinians, in one way or another, were dislocated and uprooted by Israel.  

And of course now we have a case of ethnic cleansing that even overtakes the magnitude of the ethnic cleansing during 1948.  So there is not one moment in the history of the Palestinians in Palestine since the arrival of Zionism in Palestine in which Palestinians are [not] potentially under danger of losing their home, their fields, their businesses and their homeland.



Dec 19, 2023

Ilan Pappé on the three pillars that support the Israel project

Israel is not just a state.  Israel is a project.  It is a settler colonial project.  And I do think that we are witnessing the beginning of the end of this project, because it rests on three pillars.  One is material, of coure, and there I agree.  I mean, when you use an index that looks at sustainability of the state according to their material capability, Israel is doing well...  And it does well mainly because of the United States.  So this is a condition that can change.

The second pillar is the social coherence of the settler society.  And we know that this coherence is nonexistent anymore.  There is a bit of an optical illusion because of the Hamas operation on the 7th of October that created a sense of unity.  But it's not going to cover up for the fragmentation of the society that we have seen until the 7th of October.  It seems that social coherence that is based on hatred of the Arabs or Palestinians and doesn't have very much else in common, is not very sustainable.

And more importantly than anything else, of course, there is the legitimacy pillar.  Israel enjoys the legitimacy of Western governments, or governments in the global north.  And therefore, there is a sense that it can still be sustainable because of that support of the elites.  But it has lost support of the civil societies.  And this is why probably it's the only state in the world that lobbies for its existence.  Not for its policies, not for its better economic performance, but for its very moral justification.  And it's losing that battle.

~ Ilan Pappé, "Ilan Pappe on Israel: 'We are witnessing the beginning of the end'," Middle East Eye, December 7, 2023



Nov 14, 2023

Ilan Pappé on coalition that won the Israeli elections in November 2022

Do remember what kind of a government the Israeli electorate voted for in November 2022.  They voted for a coalition that its main pillar were - not even Zionist Jews - were Messianic Jews that grew up in the settlements., who don't care about international opinion.  They think that God is on their side, and a very cruel, ruthless god is on their side.  History is on their side.  Their main problem is not just the world, but also weaklings like myself and you maybe, among the Jewish people, self-hating Jew, call them what you want.  

It's interesting how they read this event on the 7th of October.  They don't take any responsibility for this.  They say it will be a wakeup call for liberals as well to understand you cannot rely on anyone.  At the same time they're very happy that American sent two [aircraft] carriers into the Mediterranean.  

It's a moment of reckoning that we should not be misled by the optical illusions of the immediate reactions.  We have to wait and see whether these... misunderstandings about what the world has reacted to whether they will... penetrate this shield of Messianic Zionism, this extreme Zionism, that Israeli voters seem to like, judging be the results of the last elections.

~ Ilan Pappé, "Declassified Israeli Documents Reveal Dark Truths," The Majority Report, 15:30 mark, Novemer 5, 2023



Ilan Pappé on fading progressive support for Israel and illusion that October 7 Hamas attack will resurrect victim status

Look at who Israel's allies are today.  Forget about the 7th of October for a moment.  Until the 6th of October: Donald Trump, Orbán in Hungary, neo-Nazis and neo-right wing in Europe.  These are all the allies of Israel because Israel found it very difficult to resurrect alliances it had in the beginning with social democratic forces, democratic forces, not to mention movement on the Left.  The reality on the ground was too evident for people with a modicum of decency or belief in human rights and justice to say "I am a supporter of Israel today."

Israelis, by the way, lived under the illusion that what happened October 7th would erase it all.  It's amazing to read the Israeli analysis here.  They really believe that they are now absolved from everything they have done in the past and have an absolution of all they are doing now.  And the whole discourse about Israel is going to change.  No more colonialism, no more settler colonialism, no more apartheid like Amnesty International suggested.  They really believe that it almost was a painful, horrific event that enables Israel to fight more successfully the moral debt.  Of course they're totally wrong.

~ Ilan Pappé, "Declassified Israeli Documents Reveal Dark Truths," The Majority Report, 12:25 mark, November 5, 2023





Ilan Pappé on indoctrination in Israel

The society is so indoctrinated.  The Israel nation is from cradle to the grave.  You have no idea.  I can tell you because I've been indoctrinated in such a way.  It's incredible how you are indoctrinated in Israel and therefore anybody's who's brave enough to challenge it feels vulnerable.

~ Ilan Pappé, "Declassified Documents Reveal Dark Truths," The Majority Report, 10:05, November 5, 2023

Ilan Pappé on the lack of Jewish compassion for the suffering of Palestinians

Today I cannot understand educated American Jews or educated Christian Jews or educated Israelis who don't even feel a compassion towards the Palestinian suffering.  I don't even want to begin with justifications and so on, but I think the worst thing I meet in Israel, which really disturbs me, is the lack of compassion.  Of course you can see it now and you would say, "ok, now you should understand that [they] show no compassion by now [for] two thousand two hundred children that already were killed in Gaza because of the revenge."  But really?  In 2023, members of the democratic society cannot show compassion to 2,000 babies that were killed, whatever the context of what had happened?  I don't accept it.  

So I think there is something sick in the nation that I'm very glad that I liberated myself from this...  If we don't have this impulse of basic humanity within Israeli society, we will have to wait for its defeat from the outside, which I don't want... because I think it would be horrible and what we've seen Saturday [bombing Gaza] is just a prelude.  So I really hope that they will change from within and get a more universal perspective: what they have done and what they are doing.

~ Ilan Pappé, "Declassified Israeli Documents Reveal Dark Truths," The Majority Report, 6:00 mark, November 5, 2023