Showing posts with label utopianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label utopianism. Show all posts

Aug 12, 2020

Kevin Duffy on the left-right political spectrum

In the game of winner-take-all politics, two competing coalitions tend to form, narrowing the range of allowable opinion. This has given rise to left and right political ideologies, the most popular groups working within the system. Naturally, both accept the concept of government intervention whereas the out-group (libertarians) rejects this notion. The right longs for a romantic past; the left imagines a utopian future. Both advocate government intervention to get there. Like clockwork, the state grows along the path of least resistance despite the appearance of substantive disagreement.

~ Kevin Duffy, The Coffee Can Portfolio, August 11, 2020

Aug 3, 2019

Murray Rothbard on the new egalitarian Left vs. the old socialist Left

I submit that... the Left are, in their bones, “progressives,” that is, they believe, in Whig or Marxoid fashion, that History consists of an inevitable March Upward into the light, toward and into the Socialist Utopia.  They believe in the myth of inevitable progress; that History is on their side.  As Social Democrats or Mensheviks, as kissin’ or sometimes feuding cousins of the Communists or Bolsheviks, they have a similar, though not the identical ideal goal: A socialist, egalitarian State, run by bureaucrats, intellectuals, technocrats, ”therapists,” and the New Class in general in collaboration with accredited victim pressure groups striving for “equality."  These groups including, blacks, women, gays, Latinos, the disabled, and on and on.  They believe that History is marching inevitably toward that goal. A vital part of that goal is the destruction of the traditional, “bourgeois,” two-parent, nuclear family, and the bringing up of all children by the State and its New Class of licensed counselors, childcare ”givers,” and therapists.

The Utopian, march of History, goal of the Social Democrats is similar to, but not quite the same as, that of the Communists.  To the Commies, the goal was the nationalization of the means of production, the eradication of the capitalist class, and the coming to the power of the proletariat.  The Social Democrats realize that it is far better for the socialist State to retain the capitalists and a truncated market economy, to be regulated, confined, controlled, and subject to the commands of the State.  The Social Democrat goal is not ”class war,” but a kind of ”class harmony,” in which the capitalists and the market are forced to work and slave for the good of ”society” and of the parasitic State apparatus.  The Communists wanted a one-party dictatorship, with all dissenters stamped out or confined to the Gulag.  The Social-Democrats far prefer a ”soft” dictatorship, what Marcuse called, in another context, “repressive tolerance," with a two-party system where both parties agree on all fundamentals and joust politely over minor issues. (”Should we increase taxes by 5, or by 7, percent this year?”)  Freedom of speech and press will be tolerated by Social Democrats, but again only within minor and trivial limits.  Social Democrats shuddered at the naked brutality of the Gulag; what they prefer is sending dissidents to endure the “soft,” ”therapeutic” dictatorship of ”sensitivity training” and “being educated in the dignity of alternative life-styles.” In other words: Brave New World instead of 1984.  The “upward march of democracy” rather than the “dictatorship of the proletariat.”

~ Murray Rothbard, "Liberal Hysteria: The Mystery Explained," Rothbard-Rockwell Report, October 1992

Image result for liberal hysteria the mystery explained rothbard

Jul 12, 2019

David Bergland on the Utopian fallacy

This is probably the fallacy most frequently encountered in political discussions.  "Utopia" refers to the perfect society, a mythical place where everyone has everything they want all the time and nothing ever goes wrong.  There has never been such a place and never will be on this earth.  That doesn't stop the opponents of freedom from holding Utopia up as a standard.  They will contend that freedom does not guarantee that everyone will be able to achieve anything they want; some will be disappointed or frustrated and there will still be murderers, thieves, rapists and other criminals.  Because freedom does not guarantee Utopia, they argue, it should be rejected.

It is true: no advocate of freedom can guarantee Utopia.

So what?

No advocate of any political view can guarantee Utopia.

Utopia is not one of the options.  It is simply not available...

When you hear someone object to the idea of greater freedom by saying, for example, "but you cannot guarantee that all children will get a good education if we repeal compulsory school attendance laws," you are hearing the Utopian fallacy in one of its most common manifestations.

~ David Bergland, Libertarianism in One Lesson, p. 8

Image result for libertarianism in one lesson

May 7, 2008

Ludwig von Mises on romanticism

The romantic and the social art of the nineteenth century have prepared the way for socialist destructionism. Without the help it got from this direction Socialism would never have gained its hold on people's minds.

Romanticism is man's revolt against reason, as well as against the condition under which nature has compelled him to live. The romantic is a daydreamer; he easily manages in imagination to disregard the laws of logic and of nature. The thinking and rationally acting man tries to rid himself of the discomfort of unsatisfied wants by economic action and work; he produces in order to improve his position. The romantic is too weak—too neurasthenic—for work; he imagines the pleasures of success but he does nothing to achieve them. He does not remove the obstacles; he merely removes them in imagination. He has a grudge against reality because it is not like the dream world he has created. He hates work, economy, and reason.

~ Ludwig von Mises, Socialism (1922), Chapter 33

Nov 28, 2007

Hoelderlin on utopianism

What has always made the state a hell on earth has been precisely that man has tried to make it his heaven.

~ Friedrich Hoelderlin