Showing posts with label bank failures. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bank failures. Show all posts

Jul 11, 2023

Michael Lewitt on handling of SVB failure: "the government avoided a fire sale and created the time for these and other assets to recover"

While there is a great deal of handwringing about moral hazard with regard to the extension of unlimited deposit insurance at SIVB and Signature Bank (SBNY), that ship sailed a long time ago.  I think there are other lessons to be gleaned from how failing financial institutions were handled in 2008 that were applied (either knowingly or not) in this case that produced a better result.  And I think the FDIC did a reasonably good job managing a relatively orderly resolution of SIVB while minimizing any immediate systemic damage. 

The extension of unlimited deposit insurance will be debated for years but based on how the government handled the 2008 crisis, I believe it did the prudent thing here.  Had it extended a blanket guarantee on AIG’s obligations back then instead of selectively backstopping certain obligations, and also had it done the same with Lehman Brothers’ obligations rather than let the firm collapse, the losses in both cases would have been much lower and short-term and long-term damage to the financial system would have been much less.  Such a guarantee would have created the time required for these firms’ temporarily distressed assets to recover in value.  When financial institutions become distressed, the primary enemy is time.  Panic creates illiquidity which forces down prices to artificially low levels that almost invariably recover (sometimes rather quickly) once the situation stabilizes.  Today, even more than 15 years ago, time moves dangerously fast as a result of social media which accelerated the panic surrounding SIVB.  By guaranteeing the deposits at SIVB and SBNY, the government avoided a fire sale and created the time for these and other assets to recover (or begin to recover) their value, thereby avoiding unnecessary losses... 

In choosing between moral hazard and a bank run that could have caused unrepairable systemic damage, the government made the correct choice. It can address moral hazard later with measures designed to improve how banks manage their assets (including improved bank regulation), but the goal should be to live to fight another day. I would also add that the fact that depositors with more than $250,000 are almost exclusively “wealthy” as defined by the terms of our current political debates is a red herring.

~ Michael Lewitt, "Chasing Our Tails," The Credit Strategist, March 27, 2023



Michael Lewitt on the FDIC sale of Silicon Valley Bank's assets

First Citizens Bank stepped up and bought Silicon Valley Bank’s deposits and loans over the weekend, taking advantage of another bank’s mismanagement and the government’s need to support the banking system.  The deal involves the purchase of ~$72 million of assets at a $16.5 billion discount while another $90 billion of securities remain in receivership for sale by the FDIC.  What this means is that First Citizens is buying SVIB’s loans and leaving long-dated Treasuries and other investments behind for the FDIC to work out over time.  The FDIC also received equity appreciation rights in First Citizens’ holding company First Citizens Bancshares (FCNCA) with a potential value of $500 million to defray some of the potential losses on the transaction.  The 17 former branches of SIVB reopened this morning as First Citizens branches. FCNCA is rallying 40% on the news.  This should turn out to be a good move by FCNCA for which its management deserves credit.

~ Michael Lewitt, "Chasing Our Tails," The Credit Strategist, March 27, 2023



Jul 6, 2023

Lawrence White on banks runs, the FDIC and latest round of bank failures

If the uninsured depositors in Bank A can't access their funds, that's going to make the depositors in Bank B nervous, we have contagion and then we're back to 1933.

I think on the one hand, FDR [Franklin Delano Roosevelt] would be wincing and saying, "ah, man, I thought we wouldn't have screwups like this."  On the other hand, I think he would smile and say, "ah, it didn't spread, we haven't had contagion.  We haven't had widespread runs.  That was my goal in creating the FDIC."

~ Lawrence White, NYU Stern economics professor, "Everyone Wants Interest on Their Deposits. That's Bad for Main Street Banks.," The Wall Street Journal, July 6, 2023



Jun 7, 2023

Kevin Duffy on the banking crisis

In the annals of government boondoggles, the global policy of interest rate obliteration from 2008 to 2022 stands in a class by itself.  A distant second is the Covid-panicked stimulus orgy of 2020-21.  Together they created a tinderbox for fractional reserve banks, which are nothing more than poorly-run hedge funds levered to government policy.  Regulators not only failed to put out any brush fires, they provided a false sense of security while the self-proclaimed firemen (central banks) doused the economic forest with gasoline.

~ Kevin Duffy, "Regional Bank Failures: Containable or combustible?," The Coffee Can Portfolio, June 9, 2023




May 5, 2023

Tobias Adrian: "financial stability risks have been contained so far"

Financial stability risks have been contained so far and hopefully that will remain the case.  As a result, monetary policy can focus on fighting inflation and that's a desirable outcome.

[...]

I think that systemic risk has been contained to date and I'm confident in the crisis management toolkit that we have.  But I would not be surprised if there were other episodes of turmoil both in banks and nonbank financial intermediaries.

~ Tobias Adrian, IMF's director of the monetary and capital markets department, "IMF calls risks from bank crisis 'contained,' urges central banks focus on inflation," Yahoo Finance, April 13, 2023





Pierre-Oliviere Gourinchas on the health of the banking system (2023)

The good news is that the banking sector in particular is in much better overall health now than at the time, say, of the Global Financial Crisis.  There's a lot more capital, the banks are better regulated, there are all kinds of liquidity requirements, etc., especially for large banks.  And so overall the health of the banking sector is much stronger, but it doesn't mean that there couldn't be pockets of illiquidity, pockets of vulnerabilities and financial authorities need to be quite careful and monitor this because things could spread pretty quickly.

~ Pierre-Oliviere Gourinchas, International Monetary Fund chief economist, "IMF calls risks from bank crisis 'contained,' urges central banks focus on inflation," Yahoo Finance, 2:45 mark, 



May 4, 2023

Peter Schiff on bank failures: "the entire house of cards was directed by the Fed and U.S. government"

I warned for years that the banks will start collapsing for the precise reason that they're collapsing now: the Fed kept interest rates at zero for so long.  That's what allowed the institutions to load up on overpriced, low-yielding Treasuries, mortgage-backed securities and other loans.  Plus U.S. government auditors from the Fed, FDIC, they encouraged the banks to buy these long-term Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities because they gave favorable accounting treatment.  The banks didn't have to mark them to market as long as they could pretend they would hold them to maturity.  So the entire house of cards was directed by the Fed and the U.S. government, and now it's collapsing and they're acting like they have nothing to do with it and they're tying to figure out how to put out a fire that they lit.  And of course the problem is they're not putting out the fire, they're throwing gasoline on it.

~ Peter Schiff, interview with Fox Business, 4:05 mark, May 4, 2023





May 3, 2023

Mohamed El-Erian on JPMorgan's takeover of failed First Republic Bank

Look at what JPMorgan acquired.  First Republic was one of the most envied banks.  Why?  It had very rich depositors, it was able to make jumbo mortgages to very creditworthy clients and it had what was viewed as the best client experience, the best customer service.  All that is now acquired by JPMorgan at a cost that's only moderately more than what they would have lost [$5 billion] in their deposits that they put in First Republic.  So for JPMorgan, that is a great deal.  And you see that in the stock price.  Now will it make a huge difference to the bank?  No.  But at the margin it is undoubtedly and unambiguously beneficial to JPMorgan.

~ Mohamed El-Erian, interview on CNBC, May 1, 2023



Apr 11, 2023

Joseph Wang: "It looks like the banking panic is largely over"

It looks like the banking panic is largely over.  The two data points that I follow, the Fed balance sheet and my money market flow data, are showing encouraging signs.  So when a bank is in trouble, they borrow from the Fed as lender of last resort.  Weekly Fed data shows that borrowing is declining.  And we also show that money is going back into prime money market funds.  Prime money market funds lend to banks and during the panic people were pulling money away...  That's all coming back.  That tells me that the banking panic is over.

[...]

I suspect, based on the aggregate data and based on what I see in the banking system, that the large banks are going to be fine.  They're going to be in good shape.  There might be some small banks that are struggling, but we have to remember that America is a very big place.  We have 4,000 banks, most of them small, and it seems like what happened over the past month is largely regional.  So I'm optimistic.

~ Joseph Wang, Fed Guy blogger, Yahoo Finance interview, April 11, 2023



Apr 1, 2023

Cheryl Mickel: "banks are in much stronger position"

What we are facing right now is more of a test of market confidence.  You are seeing a market that doesn’t want to believe that there is still some resilience to the economy and to the banking sector. 

There are some things different in this particular “crisis” than past crises in everybody’s memories.  The economy is much stronger than it was during the [2008-09] global financial crisis.  And there has been so much regulation to build resilience that, in aggregate, banks are in much stronger position.  Also, government support is earlier, practiced, better targeted, and not dealing with the capitalization issues of the past.

~ Cheryl Mickel, head of T. Rowe Price's U.S. Taxable Low Duration Group, "A Fixed-Income Pro on Where to Park Your Cash During the Banking Tumult," Barron's, April 1, 2023



Mar 31, 2023

Michael Hiltzik blames SVB failure on "skittish depositors" and "paper losses" in bond portfolios

SVB's fundamental problem was that it had a huge number of skittish depositors, most of whose money was uninsured by the FDIC and could be withdrawn on demand, and had invested those deposits in treasuries and bonds that were generally safe, but wouldn't mature in less than 10 years.  After a series of interest rate hikes, the bonds were showing immense losses on paper.  When the depositors pulled their money — to the tune of $42 billion on March 9 — the bank couldn't liquidate its bond portfolio in a way that wouldn't convert its paper losses to real losses, so it ran out of money to pay the depositors.

~ Michael Hiltzik, "How Trump's frenzy of deregulation killed Silicon Valley Bank," Los Angeles Times, March 30, 2023



Mar 17, 2023

Richard Squire on fractional reserve banking and recent bank failures

Banking is inherently risky the way we do it in the developed world, where you have a bank that takes deposits that can leave at any time.  Depositors can demand their money and get it back at any time and then the bank turns around and invests the depositor money in long-term assets, in a 30-year mortgage or a 10-year Treasury bill or a loan to a business that might last a few years.  So this is inherently a rickety structure and when lots of depositors want to pull out their money at the same time, the bank becomes illiquid, it runs out of cash and often it fails.

So what we saw last week at SVB and to a certain extent at Signature [Bank] was a classic bank run.

~ Richard Squire, Fordham University School of Law, Yahoo Finance interview, 0:55 mark, March 17, 2023



Mar 15, 2023

Maxine Waters on recent bank failures: "this is all about regulation"

This is all about regulation and this is all about the fact that at some point in time there was great advocacy for making sure that the regional banks and the smaller banks didn't have to comply with some of the rules that perhaps would not have allowed them to get into this situation because there would've been stress testing and more oversight and more watching of what was going on.  And I certainly think all of that needs to be tightened up.

~ Rep. Maxine Waters (Dem), Financial Services Committee, "SVB collapse leads to big payday for short sellers," Yahoo Finance, 0:15 mark, March 15, 2023





Mar 12, 2023

Stephanie Pomboy on SVB failure: "this is all totally predictable"

This is all totally predictable.  When you force the banks to hold nothing but Treasuries and agencies and you ratchet up interest rates at the fastest pace in history, and drive sharp losses in those same "risk-free" assets, you're going to create some dislocations.  And I think probably what happened is that the fact that nothing untoward had occurred over the last 12 months imbued their confidence that "hey, maybe everything's going to be just fine."

~ Stephanie Pomboy, interview on Fox Business, 5:25 mark, March 11, 2023


 

Mar 11, 2023

Jim Cramer pumps SVB Financial (2023)

The ninth best performer year-to-date is SVB Financial.  This company's a merchant bank with a deposit base that Wall Street has been mistakenly concerned about...  I think the fears were not justified and it's a very compelling situation.  Hey, by the way, private equity and venture capital, they're not going away.  Being a banker to these immense pools of capital has always been a very good business.  Stock's still cheap.

~ Jim Cramer, CNBC's Mad Money, February 8, 2023



Dec 31, 2010

Howard Davidowitz sees continued problems for CRE and community banks in the US

In the end, what do you do with the retail space? This is going to be a huge question for retailers in the next ten years. That's why Wal-Mart is starting to build smaller stores. That's why Wal-Mart is building more overseas than they're building here.

[Commercial real estate landlords] already have occupancy problems, rent problems and everything else right now. I don't think commercial real estate problems are fixed by any means. That's why we're going to close hundreds of community banks going forward.

~Howard Davidowitz, chairman, Davidowitz and Associates, Bloomberg.com interview, December 31st, 2010

May 14, 2010

Alan Schwartz on speculation and rumor as the cause of the fall of Bear Stearns

During the week of March 10th, 2008, unfounded rumors and attendant speculation began circulating that Bear Stearns was in the midst of a liquidity crisis. Due to the stressed condition of the credit market as a whole and the unprecedented speed at which rumors and speculation travel and echo through the modern financial media environment, the rumors and speculation continued throughout the week. The rumors thus became a self-fulfilling prophecy and there was, simply put, a run on the bank.

~Alan Schwartz, former CEO, Bear Stearns, opening remarks of testimony given to the Financial Crisis Iniquiry Commission, May 5th, 2010

Jan 19, 2009

Ben Bernanke: large global banks sound (2008)

I expect there will be some failures. … I don't anticipate any serious problems of that sort among the large internationally active banks that make up a very substantial part of our banking system.

~ Ben Bernanke, Federal Reserve chairman, February 28, 2008

(In September, Washington Mutual became the largest financial institution in U.S. history to fail. Citigroup needed an even bigger rescue in November.)