Showing posts with label people - Levy; Gideon. Show all posts
Showing posts with label people - Levy; Gideon. Show all posts

Dec 24, 2023

Gideon Levy on the dehumanization of Palestinians by Israelis

By the end of the day, how many Israelis did ever try, for a moment, to put themselves in the place of the Palestinians, for a moment, for one day?  And I want to give you two examples which will demonstrate it.

Many years ago, I interviewed then candidate for Prime Minister, Ehud Barak.  And I asked him a question which I try to ask in any occasion: "Mr. Barak, what would have happened if you would have been born Palestinian?"  And Barak gave me the only honest answer he could give me.  He said "I would have joined the terror organization."  What else would he have done?  Would he become a poet?  He doesn't know to write poems.  Would he become a pianist?  He's quite a bad pianist and I doubt he would have become a collaborator because he is a fighter.  And it became a scandal because how can you dare to put Ehud Barak to think what would have happened if he would have become a Palestinian.

And the second incident briefly: second intifada, the city of Jenin, the most closed city in the West Bank, real, total seige.  I go out from Jenin, I come to the checkpoint, Palestinian ambulances parking there with the red lights.  I stand after him.  No cars can get out of Jenin in those days, no cars can get out, and I wait.  The soldiers are playing backgammon in the tent.  Usually, I know, I know myself, it's better that I don't get into confrontation with the soldiers because it always ends up very badly.  So I stayed in the car.

But after 40 minutes, I couldn't take it.  And I went out from the car, I went first to the Palestinian ambulance driver and I asked him, "What's going on?"  He told me, "That's the routine.  They let me wait one hour until they come and check the ambulance."  And I couldn't take it anymore and I went to the soldiers.  It became a confrontation.  But the question that I asked them which really brought them to direct their weapons toward me was one: "What would have happened if your father would have been lying in this ambulance?"  This freaked them out.  They lost control.  How can I dare to compare between their father and the Palestinian in the ambulance?  And this set of beliefs, that they are not human beings like us, enable us - Israelis - to live in so much peace with those crimes, ongoing crimes, for so many years, with losing any kind of humanity, values.

I heard today, people talk about Jewish values.  I must be frank with you, I don't know what are Jewish values.  I know what are universal values.

~ Gideon Levy, "How Israelis Live So Easily With Occupation," Saad Tasleem, 3:35 mark, November 7, 2023



Dec 18, 2023

Gideon Levy on how Israelis live with the occupation

The Israel society has surrounded itself with shields, with walls, not only physical walls, but also mental walls...  I'll just give these three principles which enable us Israelis to live so easily with this brutal reality.  A: Most of the Israelis, if not all of them, deeply believe that we are the chosen people.  And if we are the chosen people, we have the right to do whatever we want.  B: There were more brutal occupations in history.  There were even longer occupations in history, even though the Israeli occupation gets to quite a nice record.  But there was never in history an occupation in which an occupier presented himself as the victim.  Not only the victim, the only victim around.  This also enable any Israeli to live in peace because we are the victims...  

But the third set of values is the most dangerous one.  And this is the systematic dehumanization of the Palestinians which enables us Israelis to live in peace with everything.  Because if they are not human beings like us, then there is not really a question of human rights.  And if you scratch under the skin of almost every Israeli, you will find it there.  Almost no one will treat the Palestinians as equal human beings like us.

~ Gideon Levy, "How Israelis Live So Easily With Occupation," Saad Tasleem, November 7, 2023



Nov 28, 2023

Gideon Levy on the Six-Day War

From the military point of view, it was indeed a "glorious" war, which was seen as justified.  But it was also a war that generated a fundamental transformation in Israeli society.  It led to the growth of unbridled national arrogance, which exacted an awful price in blood over the past 50 years and turned the military victory into a moral defeat.  In retrospect, it should be called the 50 Year War, not the Six-day war, and judging by the political situation, its life expectancy appears endless.

I think most Israelis will be quite indifferent.  It is a society in denial.  It is a society totally preoccupied with private affairs.  No one but the settlers will celebrate.  But, also, no one will mourn.  In that respect, Gush Etzion is the right place to mark it, because only settlers will feel the day.  In Tel Aviv, people couldn’t care less and no artificial effort by the government can change that.

~ Gideon Levy, Haaretz, April 7, 2017




Nov 14, 2023

Gideon Levy on the sham of Israeli democracy

Gideon Levy: At the end of the day we have to realize that the world is supporting Israel, almost blindly and automatically.  And I don't see a way to change it, but through civil societies, not governments.  Governments will not change.

Q: Towards what goal, then?  Just a democratic state for everyone in that land?

Levy: What else is left?  If the two-state solution is dead, as I think, we are facing only a one-state.  Now one state we have for 50 years.  It's not a new invention now.  Now we have one state.  The only problem is, is that it has nothing to do with democracy because as long as you govern another people in such a brutal way, through military occupying force, you have nothing to do with democracy.  Even if it's only in your backyard.  But it is there.  It is in our backyard.  Even if in the front Israel is this lovely darling of the West, with its lovely, charming liberal democracy for its Jews, in their backyard there is one of the most brutal tyrannies on earth.  

So this cannot be perceived as democracy.  The struggle must be, from now on, to change this reality.  In other words, to change the regime between the river and the Mediterranean.  Changing the regimes means to go for real democracy.  Who is against democracy again?  I would like to know, in this country [the U.S.], in my country, who is opposing democracy?

Q: Well, the problem in Israel is the majority of Israelis who are opposed to real democracy.

Levy: So let's call them by their names.  So they are racist.  So it's an apartheid state.

Q: No argument there, but the question is, is it realistic to believe that that can be overcome, that that can be changed, especially when they have the vital support of the U.S.?  That's why I'm asking, what is more likely to be attained, this unjust two-state solution or something that no Israeli, at least right now, would ever agree to?

Levy: Look, the Israelis don't agree to both.  The Israelis want to have it all.  They want to be Jewish and democratic and occupying.  If it goes according to what the Israelis are ready to do, it means continuing the status quo forever.  Let me be doubtful that this is possible, because no colonial force lasted forever.  And no empire, even, lasted forever.  When it is so rotten from the inside, rotten morally, it cannot last forever.

~ Gideon Levy, "Netanyahu or Not, Israel is Corrupted (2/2)," The Real News Network, 8:45 mark, March 7, 2018