Showing posts with label malinvestment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label malinvestment. Show all posts

Jan 23, 2026

Rajiv Jain on AI malinvestment

I foresee disappointment.  We talk to dozens of companies monthly and large consulting firms focused on the AI rollout.  There is almost no evidence of profit-margin improvement.  People use AI to summarize email and do ChatGPT-type searches.  Ninety percent of ChatGPT use is outside the U.S. 

An important MIT study came out over the summer that found that 95% of AI projects found no real use.  In our view, Microsoft Copilot has been a total failure…  GPU pricing is in free fall.  Based on our research, Nvidia’s Blackwell chips can be rented for $4.00 an hour.  Blackwell chips are already being rented at a discount versus just a few months ago.  If demand was so strong, why have Blackwell rentals been collapsing? 

There are 200 neocloud companies today.  Depreciation rates are out of line with reality.  H200 chips, for example, were selling at 50%-plus off within nine months of release.  A few large enterprises mentioned to us that real economic life when used for training is barely 18 to 24 months.

Most of the growth at the cloud hyperscalers is coming from start-ups, and who is funding these start-ups?  More than half of the $150 billion that start-ups invested in the cloud was funded by the large tech companies.  This is a giant, circular trade.  I agree with Henry [Ellenbogen] that a lot of smaller companies will see productivity gains from AI, but margins are falling at the cloud providers.  There is an incentive for semiconductor companies and other tech companies to talk up the benefits of AI, but there is little evidence of profit-margin improvement almost anywhere because of AI, except at companies selling shovels to the gold diggers.

~ Rajiv Jain, "The Roundtable: Part 1," Barron's, January 10, 2026

 

Jan 22, 2026

Louis-Vincent Gave on how China will commoditize the AI business

Take a step back, what's the biggest price anomaly?...  I think a massive price anomaly is the share price of Nvidia and the share price of Facebook [Meta Platforms] and the share price of all these guys that are today incinerating cash on the hope and promise that this cash is going to lead to outsize returns, but it won’t.  It won’t because, unlike the smartphone revolution, unlike previous booms, this time around China is in the AI room.  And what I’ve learned out of 30 years of being in China is that when China enters the room, profits walk out.  And if you’re competing with China, you’ve taken a wrong turn in your life.

~ Louis-Vincent Gave, "China Just Ended 100 Years of American Dominance," RiskReversal Podcast, 42:45 mark, December 15, 2026

Louis-Vincent Gave on the AI malinvestment in the U.S.

I think that [AI] in the U.S. is a huge misallocation of resources.  In the U.S. the business model essentially is, “Oh, we’re going to get 500 million customers that pay us $20 each a month.”…  I’m very skeptical that anybody will do it when China is giving it for free…  In China, the development of AI has a lot more to do with, “How do we use this for our factories… essentially getting rid of industrial workers?”…  If you think there are three goals: One is to make factories more efficient.  I can see how that’s going to happen.  In fact… it’s already happening.  If the goal is, “We’re going to get rid of low-end service workers – the paralegals, banking analysts, etc.,” that might very well happen.  I think it is starting to happen.  You see it in the rise of youth unemployment here, etc., but that also comes with big social consequences.  And if the end goal is AGI [artificial general intelligence], I’m actually super dubious on that…  [T]he whole AGI thing is being sold to us as investors: “Do this, give us billions and we’re going to deliver AGI on the other side.  I think it’s a stock promote,… literally the Vancouver guy trying to sell you a gold mine standing next to a hole.

~ Louis-Vincent Gave, "China Just Ended 100 Years of American Dominance," RiskReversal Podcast, 45.35 mark, December 15, 2026

 

Aug 17, 2024

Scott Barbee on future oil consumption

Generally, oil demand has been dominated overwhelmingly by long term consumption growth trends in Asia, as China, India and other developing countries relentlessly increase their per capita oil consumption.  Such trends are also quite likely to continue well into the future, despite the multitude of political narratives de rigueur against fossil fuels, as 7 billion people on earth who consume an average of 3 bbls/yr desire to live like the other 1 billion who consume an average of 16 bbls/year.  Increased use of low-cost, fossil fuel energy remains critical to the alleviation of poverty and a more inclusive global economic development, with fossil fuel energy demand unlikely to easily or inexpensively be supplanted by alternatives through government fiat.  Goldman Sachs' commodities analyst Jeff Currie recently pointed out that $3.8 trillion in investment in renewables has been spent over the last 10 years.  These expenditures have been financed to a large extent from taxpayer handouts and through other government market distortions.  However, despite all these costly expenditures over the last 10-years, the share of total global energy consumption met by fossil fuels has only dropped by one percent, from 82 percent to 81 percent.

~ Scott L. Barbee, portfolio manager, Aegis Value Fund, "Aegis Value Fund H1 2023 Portfolio Manager's Letter," Seeking Alpha, December 13, 2023

Jul 31, 2024

Larry McDonald on the AI capital spending binge

Yesterday, we had an interesting chat where, it was a private conversation with a guy in the Valley [Silicon Valley] that is really good friends with all of the CFOs of the Mag 7.  He's been out to dinner with them hundreds of times, he's been in the Valley for over 30 years and he's run hedge fund money...  And we had another guy who's been trading semiconductors for 20 years professionally and they were having this conversation around artificial intelligence.  And the one thing they both said... it's like the Manhattan Project where if you're a CFO in the Valley and you're not doubling or tripling your capex the last year and a half in artificial intelligence, you're fired.  They're so terrified to be, two years from now, left on the outside.  So what's fascinating is... the capex has gone from like $30 billion a year to $160 billion a year with no visibility...  There's zero visibility on return on capital.  So this is capital expenditures just being deployed at a sick, aggressive, insane pace.  He called it a "Reagan-Gorbachev arms race" where the CFOs have a gun to their head.  They have to invest...  It's created these distortions where Wall Street analysts are falling all over themselves to upgrade Nvidia, but this capex trajectory is just not sustainable.  And the market's starting to figure it out now.

~ Larry McDonald, "Buy What Wall Street Hates," Stansberry Investor Hour, 26:40 mark, July 29, 2024



Jul 11, 2023

Michael Lewitt on commercial real estate loans coming due

Even more concerning is what will happen as commercial real estate loans mature and have to be refinanced at much higher rates.  Chris White at Loop Capital noted this morning that there are $147 billion of real estate loans coming due over the next 12-24 months with an average coupon of 4.3% while the current prime rate is 8%.  Rates may decline by the time these loans come due but will certainly remain at least 200-300 basis points higher than the original loans.  Many projects that penciled out in ZIRP are not economic anymore.  Many experts are forecasting loss rates of as high as 40% on commercial real estate based not merely on higher interest rates but lower utilization rates of urban (and even suburban) office buildings.  Commercial real estate was a major participant in the ZIRP/QE bubble and is now experiencing a painful and expensive adjustment as that bubble deflates.  A city like San Francisco, for example, is directly in the bullseye of higher rates, a tech bust, and the physical destruction of the urban environment.

~ Michael Lewitt, "Chasing Our Tails," The Credit Strategist, March 27, 2023



Sep 7, 2022

Jim Grant on the everything bubble's malinvestments

I think the way to imagine this is to put ourselves in mind of the old college freshman fraternity initiation trick, and that is yanking a tablecloth out from under a set table of china, glassware and porcelain.  Now, if you go on WikiHow to investigate how to do this, WikiHow will advise, "Always try it with plastic cutlery and cups."  But notice the Fed has not got that option because the table is set proverbially and metaphorically... with the most brittle glassware and the most precious porcelain and bull market champagne flutes because of 12 years of suppressed interest rates which have fostered risk taking, which have brought forth into the world all these companies called unicorns because they come to market with a billion dollars and generate not much earnings.  So the world is full of uneconomic economic projects, fostered through financial stimulus, principally low interest rates, right?

So, what happens when you raise the rate of interest on companies that need to borrow just to stay alive?  Well, they can't stay alive, so they're cascading failures.  And companies supply those uneconomic things.  Think of craft beer makers that sold beer to WeWork in the day, right?  So there's a whole chain of economic activity that goes to support uneconomic activity.

So that's the metaphor for the yanking the tablecloth.

~ Jim Grant, interview with William Green, 58:15 mark, August 20, 2022



Jul 21, 2021

Kevin Duffy on Netflix and woke content

Over the past five years, Netflix has taken on $10 billion in debt to create a lot of woke content.  What happens when the woke bubble eventually bursts?  Will Netflix be sitting on a collection of disco records that end up in a landfill?

~ Kevin Duffy, July 21, 2021



Jun 1, 2021

Myles Udlard on AMC Entertainment's $230 million capital raise

Q: The thing that's funny about this is they're raising cash to buy assets, to buy more of a thing that's not full already?  So we'll see how that strategy works out over the longer term.  It doesn't really matter, I guess, but if you're going to spend the cash, buy more movie theaters?

Myles Udlard: That makes sense.  They're in the movie theater business.  It goes all the way back to Hertz.  Hertz last year was being told by the market that it didn't have to file for bankruptcy and so these CEO are now looking at the meme market and they're saying, "Screw it.  I will go on offense.  The market is telling me to do that, whether it's a joke on Reddit or not."

~ Myles Udlard, "AMC higher on $230M capital raise," 3:05 mark, Yahoo Finance, June 1, 2021



Apr 23, 2021

Adam Smith on spendthrift governments

Great nations are never impoverished by private, though they sometimes are by public prodigality and misconduct.  The whole, or almost the whole public revenue, is in most countries employed in maintaining unproductive hands.

~ Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, p. 325



Dec 27, 2020

Mike Green on how passive investing is distorting capital allocation

That is actually a very important role: taking money from bad companies and giving it to good companies is a critical role in the capitalist system, effectively allowing those who are efficient and intelligent allocators of capital, to give money to management teams that have good prospects in terms of generating future wealth.  What we've created now is a distortion that's a funhouse mirror effect, right?  Where we've presumed everyone is doing this for us where it is a fool's game to do it for ourselves.

~ Mike Green, "Why The Rise of Passive Investing Might Be Distorting The Market," Odd Lots podcast with Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway, January 23, 2020



Jun 15, 2020

Jim Grant on how leveraged finance leads to complacency

Maybe it's in the nature of leveraged finance that prosperity leads to complacency and complacency to error and error to crisis.  But how much more explosive is this chain of causation when complacency has an official sponsor in the Federal Reserve Board.

~ Jim Grant, "Chairman Powell meets Professor Goodhart," Grant's Interest Rate Observer, June 12, 2020

Jenga - Wikipedia

May 29, 2020

Kevin Duffy on the downside of ZIRP

In addition to fake news and fake science, we now have fake interest rates sending fake signals to businesses and investors attempting to allocate capital, and to governments more than willing to squander it.

~ Kevin Duffy, The Coffee Can Portfolio, May 27, 2020, p. 12

Cartoon of the Day: ZIRP Doggy Dogg


Nov 30, 2019

Kevin Duffy looks under economic hood and applies free lunch fallacy to NIRP and QE

There is no free lunch. Polices like negative interest rates and Quantitative Easing are doing damage to the underlying economic engine. They misallocate capital, discourage thrift and promote fast money over slowly building wealth. At the end of the day, central banks are not all powerful. They are not immune to the laws of economics.

~ Kevin Duffy, "Central Bankers Are Starting to Lose Control," The Market, November 19, 2019

Image result for transformers megan fox car breaking down

May 29, 2019

WeWork CFO on how investors should treat losses

We really want to emphasize the difference between losing money and investing money. You can lose money or you can invest money. At the end of this quarter, we have these cash flow-generating assets.

~ Artie Minson, WeWork CFO, as appeared on CNBC, May 22, 2019

Dec 20, 2018

Jim Grant is asked about Fed chairman Jerome Powell's press conference and stock market's negative reaction

Grant: I don't think it's a matter of communications policy.  I think it's a matter of substance.  To me, the clear and present risk is the consequences - unintended though they may be - of ten years of suppressed and distorted interest rates with the attendant distortions in both the so-called real economy and especially in the financial economy where leverage has been piled upon leverage.

CNBC: So this is inevitable, this kind of negative reaction.

Grant: Certainly after ten years of the lowest interest rates, literally in the 3,000 years of recorded history.

CNBC: We get that you didn't agree with the policy before, but right now are they making a mistake?

Grant: It's not a question of agreeing with it.  The consequences of ten years of distorted interest rates are things that we can't always see, but which are nonetheless there.  For example, the distortions of the leveraged loan market with fine print that's supposed to protect investors has been eviscerated or written down.  Green investments proliferate because there are no interest rates.  Interest rates are meant to measure risk, discount future cash flows and set investment hurdle rates.  When those things are absent or distorted, decisions in real time - real things - are not as they might be.  And exactly what is wrong is revealed in time.  Now, the stock market is a forward looking indicator.  The economy is not a forward looking indicator, right?

~ Jim Grant, interview on CNBC, December 19, 2018

Oct 9, 2009

Ludwig von Mises on the impoverishment of the boom

The boom squanders through malinvestment scarce factors of production and reduces the stock available through overconsumption; its alleged blessings are paid for by impoverishment.

~ Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (1949)

May 7, 2008

Murray Rothbard on the drug of credit expansion

Why do booms historically continue for several years? The answer is that as the boom begins to peter out from an injection of credit expansion, the banks inject a further dose. In short, the only way to avert the onset of the depression is to continue inflating money and credit. For only continual doses of new money on the credit market will keep the boom going and the new stages profitable. Furthermore, only ever increasing doses can step up the boom, can lower interest rates further, and expand the production structure, for as the prices rise, more and more money will be needed to perform the same amount of work. Once the credit expansion stops, the market ratios are re-established, and the seemingly glorious new investments turn out to be malinvestments, built on a foundation of sand. It is clear that prolonging the boom by ever larger doses of credit expansion will have only one result: to make the inevitably ensuing depression longer and more grueling.

~ Murray Rothbard